The Jews Who Played Cards
Originally published on Gimme Some Torah by Rabbi Eli Garfinkel on November 13, 2026.

Photo by Izzy Park on Unsplash
In this week’s seder, both Jacob and Rebecca engage in morally complicated behavior. It is not right to deny this; doing anything of consequence often requires making uncomfortable choices. If it were easy to do the right thing, then everyone would do it!
Jacob committed a kind of fraud when he demanded Eisav’s birthright in exchange for a lousy bowl of lentil stew. Later, he and Rebecca outright stole Esau’s paternal blessing. These are not merely possible accusations; the Torah tells explicitly us what they did.
However, one who judges another must always look at the larger context. A Hasidic story makes this very point:
The righteous Rabbi Yechiel Michel of Zlotshov (bio) used to travel among Jewish communities, delivering sermons to the public. First and foremost, he would focus his sermons on the refinement of character traits and the cultivation of better interpersonal relationships. Throughout his life, he strictly avoided speaking ill of any Jew, always striving to judge those who had sinned in a favorable light.
Once, several of his close associates came to him and reported that a group of Jews had recently begun gathering in a certain house to play cards for most of the night.
The Tzaddik’s expression darkened upon hearing this, yet he refrained from judging the card players harshly. Instead, he said to his associates: “These Jews, it seems, wish to serve the Creator—blessed be His Name—throughout the day and the night. Consequently, they are currently training themselves to remain awake during the nighttime hours. Once this habit becomes firmly established, they will—with God’s help—dedicate their spare time to the service of the Creator and attain complete repentance…” — See Parpera’ot LaTorah, Menahem Becker, ed. (Jerusalem: Omen Publishers, 1986), vol. 1, p. 89.
So it is with Jacob and Rebecca. True, they stole the blessing from Esau and deceived Isaac. But by stealing that blessing, they put themselves on a path toward holiness. Their story is an important part of our own.
Before you judge somebody, make sure you understand the whole story.
•••
Rabbi Eli L. Garfinkel is the Senior Rabbi of Temple Beth El in Somerset, New Jersey.
Temple Beth El is a great Jewish community—check us out!
Would you like to study Talmud with me in our lunch and learn group (Zoom and in person)? Click the message button below!
Kosher Duck Revolution is an initiative of AIC. Join AIC. Membership starts at $9 a month.