She Threw Away His Ballot!
Originally published on Rabbi Smason’s beehiiv on November 19, 2026.
Several years ago, Isaac Pollak, an enthusiastic Republican, was preparing to leave town. Before departing, he handed his absentee ballot for the upcoming presidential election to his wife, Bonnie, and asked her to mail it.
There was just one problem: Bonnie was a Democrat.
Faced with a choice between respecting her husband’s vote and remaining faithful to her political convictions, Bonnie made her decision. She threw his ballot in the trash.
When Isaac eventually discovered what she’d done, he was speechless. But did Bonnie do something to show Isaac that she loved him more than she disagreed with him?
✨3 Ideas
- **Disagreeing while staying connected **
Differences in politics, religion, and other deeply held beliefs sometimes strain even our closest relationships. But the people we love are far more than the opinions they hold.
Beneath our differences lies a shared humanity and a natural desire for connection. **It is possible to hold firmly to our convictions without loosening our hold on the people we love. **
We have far more in common with one another than the opinions that divide us. That common ground offers a starting point for staying connected, even when we disagree.
- **Why do disagreements turn ugly? **
Two people can hold opposite opinions, each convinced they’re right. Yet one may discuss their differences respectfully, while the other becomes angry or confrontational. What accounts for the difference?
Our ego often gets in the way.
When someone challenges our beliefs, we may feel they’re questioning our intelligence or judgment. We may also fear that appearing wrong will make us look weak or diminish the respect others have for us.
- **Be a judge, not a lawyer **
When we disagree with someone, it’s tempting to behave like a lawyer, assertively advocating our position. But when we approach disagreements like a judge, we carefully weigh the evidence and calmly consider another perspective.
**Our goal should be to engage in a discussion, not to win an argument. **
How? Ask sincere questions, look for common ground, and acknowledge a worthwhile point even when we disagree with the other person’s position.
📜2 Quotes
“A gentle reply turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger.” — Proverbs 15:1
“Never go to bed mad. Stay up and fight.” — _Phyllis Diller _
❓1 Question
Why is it so hard to talk with people about things we disagree with?
So, what became of Isaac and Bonnie Pollak, our politically divided couple?
Despite her own political convictions, Bonnie wrote to President George W. Bush, whom Isaac greatly admired, requesting a written greeting for Isaac’s 60th birthday.
To her delight, President Bush sent a letter. And when Isaac discovered the surprise, his excitement made Bonnie’s efforts worthwhile. The couple still watched the Republican convention in separate rooms. But Bonnie had demonstrated something far more important than political agreement.
Sometimes, the most important thing we can agree on is that our relationship matters more than our disagreements.
Until next time, Wishing you a week of good conversations and greater understanding,
Rabbi Ze’ev Smason
P.S. Have you recently had a disagreement that could have become heated, but remained civil? What made the difference? I’d love to hear the story.
Kosher Duck Revolution is an initiative of AIC. Join AIC. Membership starts at $9 a month.
